Thank you for visiting paducahsun.com, the online home of The Paducah Sun.

June 2012
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

Click here to submit an event.

Working class socially disconnected

By MICHAEL GERSON Washington Post Writers Group

WASHINGTON - Much about the future health of the republic depends on Harvard sociologist Robert Putnam being wrong. Given the track record of Harvard social scientists, this might appear a reasonable bet. But, in this case, Putnam's diligence and thoughtfulness make for very bad news.

Putnam has spent much of his academic life as America's chief chronicler of declining social institutions - a dour task, cheerfully performed. In the 1990s, he began drawing together the disparate evidence of declining attendance at bowling leagues, church services and Moose lodges. His data points included the falloff in yearly picnic attendance and a rise in the incidence of drivers giving each other the finger.

It was the composite image of one of the most powerful forces of modernity: a rising individualism that "liberates" people from social commitments that make their lives orderly and pleasant.

Even worse, the extent of this trend is not distributed equally in society. Putnam's recent work - to be summarized in a forthcoming book "Our Kids" - focuses on how the consequences of institutional decline are felt disproportionately among the working class, leaving vast numbers of youth disconnected from the promise of American life.

Upper- and middle-class parents are investing relatively more time and resources in the social development of their children than are working-class parents, at a time when such investments have never been more economically strategic.

The problem is that early social connectedness is a strong predictor of later success in life - test scores, college attendance and income. So what Putnam calls the "youth class gap" is a source of deep (and perhaps deepening) social division.

If income inequality is the main economic problem, it could be solved tomorrow, through confiscation and redistribution. If the main problem is the unequal generation of social capital in institutions such as families, schools and communities, the solutions get more difficult. One task can be accomplished by a tax collector; the other is the work of a civilization.

Putnam's analysis both illuminates the complexity of public policy choices and increases the likelihood that policy solutions could gain broad political support. His proposed explanations for the disproportionate decline in social connectedness among the working class are ideologically diverse. "Decreasing social mobility," he argues, "represents a perfect storm with multiple, interrelated causes, such as [a] widening income gap and increasing economic insecurity for working-class households, changes in the working-class family structure [and the] unraveling of the informal social safety net in working-class neighborhoods."

These arguments are rooted in observation rather than ideology. But they create the possibility of ideological consensus, or at least of ideological compromise. Proposals focused mainly on reducing income inequality require the political triumph of the left. Conservatives, being conservatives, will not concede leveling as a valid economic goal. But an agenda that increases the rewards of work, encourages stable, engaged families and promotes healthy community institutions could be a shared political enterprise.

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Your comment has been submitted for approval
captcha 9a504591454246b380356e212da883e0
Top Classifieds
  • Seasoned Firewood. 243-5815 Details
  • Deutz-Fahr Cab Loader 4X4, Clean, 270 ... Details
  • Cash for farms & gold (270)339-8 ... Details
  • RUNNING, fixable, junk vehicles, equi ... Details
  • PILLOW TOPmattress sets NEW in plasti ... Details
  • SEEING is believing! Don't buy p ... Details
  • Dodge Intrepid $500 281.565.5629 Details
  • Harley Davidson 1994 Softtail Spring ... Details
  • 02 HD Softail Duece,82k,$6,500 (270) ... Details
  • 2001 Corvette Convertible, Heads Up D ... Details
  • Scarlet Red Road Glide 1 owner 33K Mi ... Details
This Week In Photos
Most Popular
  1. Supreme Court ruling at odds with God's law
  2. Latter-day Saints' tenets are often misunderstood
  3. SPECTATOR Syria bumbling leaves Russia, Iran running show
  1. Most of region's school districts meet test goals
  2. Drugged driving deaths increase
  3. Two injured after semi rolls over
  1. Gubernatorial debate was depressing
  2. Supreme Court ruling at odds with God's law
  3. Latter-day Saints' tenets are often misunderstood

Check out these recently discussed stories and voice your opinion...