Welcome

Thank you for visiting paducahsun.com, the online home of The Paducah Sun.

Calendar
June 2012
S M T W T F S
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

Click here to submit an event.

Advancing on merit a murky concept

By SUSAN ESTRICH Creators Syndicate

What's wrong with a meritocracy rug? Nothing, right? For much of my professional life, I yearned for an opportunity to be judged on the basis of my accomplishments, without regard to factors such as race or sex. In my version of the American dream, the country was a meritocracy that allowed you to succeed even if your mother was a secretary and a lot of people seemed to hate Jews.

So how come so many feminists were angry about the "United Meritocracy of GitHub" rug that they ultimately decided to take it down?

According to Julie Ann Horvath, an engineer at the company who founded the all-female lecture series Passion Projects and defended the company at the time, the problem began on some of the feminist tech talk boards, where women pointed out some painfully obvious questions: If it's really a meritocracy, how come so few of the people at the top are women?

Or more broadly, if you believe we've achieved "equality" and that decisions are being made based on merit, how come the industry's leadership - particularly in the tech industry, where the leadership is very young - is so overwhelmingly male?

Some of it, certainly, is the reflection of the stubborn under-representation of women in STEM fields, especially computer science, which Harvey Mudd College President Maria Klawe has taken a leadership role in trying to change, as well as the related problem of the tech "culture," which Horvath herself was tackling with her Passion Projects.

In the meantime, GitHub decided to yank the rug. That was in January. Frankly, I missed it - the story, not the rug.

I caught up this week when Horvath rather noisily exited (or was asked to leave) and started firing at the company she previously had defended. But Horvath claims she was threatened and intimidated by the wife of one of the founders (using a wife as an agent of intimidation, if that is indeed what happened, is not a feminist act), and also that as a woman she never felt accepted at the company. Horvath also was having a relationship with a fellow employee, and - this will not come as a shock to feminists of a certain age - he still has his job, while she doesn't have hers.

Meritocracies actually are more complicated than they first appear. They require a common appreciation of what counts as "merit" and how it should be measured.

Most people tend to think that the most qualified person is someone who looks just like them, only younger. Ask them whether they're discriminating, and they'll say you're crazy. Just the merits. And many of the traits we value, and how we value them, also end up being laden with gender overtones.

Getting crosswise with your boss's wife is a career ender that disproportionately ensnares women. Sexist? Absolutely. At first, I couldn't understand why the tech feminists were so worked up about the rug. The answer, as always, is that it's never just the rug.

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Your comment has been submitted for approval
captcha ff908e24acb9400b8bef86c0379b5b09
Top Classifieds
  • HAVANESE PUPS AKC Home Raised, Best H ... Details
  • Cocker Spaniel Pup - AKC (270)476-258 ... Details
  • RUNNING, fixable, junk vehicles, equi ... Details
  • Hummel Figurines & Plates, Carniv ... Details
  • Cash for farms & gold (270)339-8 ... Details
  • Mature Professional Seeks to rent hou ... Details
  • PILLOW TOPmattress sets NEW in plasti ... Details
  • Pride lift chair, excellent working c ... Details
  • 16x80 2 bd., 2 b, Call for info. $17 ... Details
  • 4010 Maxon Rd. 1.33 Acres, 4 BD. 3.5 ... Details
  • Your HOME Team RealtorsOPEN HOUSE Tod ... Details
  • 4BD 2 BA Home 6080 Woodville Rd Banda ... Details
  • SEEING is believing! Don't buy p ... Details
  • 185 AC. ESTATE Rolling hills, l ... Details
  • FAIRHURST BLDG.295 sq. ft. office1900 ... Details
  • Ford Mustang '04 V6 78k $4,900 2 ... Details
  • FOR SALE: 2012 Hyundai Santa Fe SUV 4 ... Details
  • 2000 Dutchman 20 ft Pop-up Camper. Ve ... Details
  • JOE'S BACKHOE SERVICE Install &a ... Details
  • FOR SALE: 1993 Honda GL1500AP Goldwin ... Details
This Week In Photos
Most Popular
  1. Illinois will become first state to lock painkiller pill bottles
  2. In our schools
  3. Trump courts tea party voters at Nashville event
  1. Tilghman students take close look at health care careers
  2. Costume wars heat up early
  3. Tasty downtown success story
  1. Illinois will become first state to lock painkiller pill bottles
  2. In our schools
  3. Trump courts tea party voters at Nashville event
Discussion

Check out these recently discussed stories and voice your opinion...