Welcome

Thank you for visiting paducahsun.com, the online home of The Paducah Sun.

Calendar
June 2012
S M T W T F S
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

Click here to submit an event.

Social media used as legal evidence

BY ANDREA MOORE amoore@paducahsun.com

Members of the local criminal justice community are seeing social media used more often as evidence in court.

"We do see Facebook postings quite often used to impeach witnesses, where witnesses testify to one thing and then are questioned on something that may be different than their testimony," said McCracken Circuit Court Judge Tim Kaltenbach.

Chris McNeil, directing attorney of the McCracken County Public Defender's Office, said he has seen Facebook posts in court more often.   

"We are seeing Facebook being mentioned in court in all kinds of different situations," said McNeil.  

Jamie Mills, a public defender in McCracken County, said he often uses social media to impeach witnesses that he is cross-examining.  

"I always check social media, particularly in juvenile cases, before anyone testifies," said Mills.  "I also use it to see if a witness has any bias."  

The Supreme Court of Kentucky issued an unpublished opinion in Simmons v. Commonwealth, a case that originated in McCracken County Circuit Court, that involved Facebook posts being used as evidence.  

In the Simmons case, the posts were used to convict a man of first-degree sexual abuse, third-degree sodomy, third-degree rape, and of being a second-degree persistent felony offender.  The court ruled that the trial court did not abuse its discretion and properly admitted the Facebook messages as evidence.  

"Facebook is a great investigative tool," Paducah Police Department Detective Justin Crowell said. "It is generally speaking something that you will try to check when investigating a case. "

Crowell said that detectives often use social media to investigate allegations and sometimes it can help prove or disprove cases.  He said detectives will submit social media to prosecutors.      

Kentucky State Police Detective Sgt. Dean Patterson said he turns to social media in the vast majority of cases. 

"We use social media as a tool to get circumstantial or exculpatory evidence," Patterson said. "Many times in the early stages of an investigation we use it to get a lead."

Patterson explained that social media time stamps when someone has logged on and where they have been.

"Our intelligence analysts dig up all they can when investigating a case," he said.

Contact Andrea Moore, a Sun staff writer, at 270-575-8684.

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Your comment has been submitted for approval
captcha 780c2c23420d4e8d92bdc9a33a0d1dc8
Top Classifieds
  • HAVANESE PUPS AKC Home Raised, Best H ... Details
  • Tiny Schnauzer Pups,Paper-trained 270 ... Details
  • Use Happy Jack Flea Powder to control ... Details
  • Adorable Yorkie Puppies. Tails & ... Details
  • PILLOW TOPmattress sets NEW in pl ... Details
  • SAWMILLS from only $4397.00 - MAKE &# ... Details
  • Downsizing Due To Health Museum Quali ... Details
  • RELOADER: 12 ga. HORNADY 3.0 halls, p ... Details
  • Details
  • MOVE IN ready mobile homes. Owner fin ... Details
  • 1 bdrm., c/a, c/h, $19,000 orMake o ... Details
  • FAIRHURST BUILDING Professional Offic ... Details
  • CONCORD AREA MCHS - 3 miles ... Details
  • 1/2 acre lot Terre Verte subdivision ... Details
  • 58 Acres of prime farm ground. On Cum ... Details
  • SEEING is believing! Don't b ... Details
  • WANTED TO BUY: Rough, Cut, Timberland ... Details
  • 2007 Taurus,92K mi, purchased in 2008 ... Details
  • Lincoln Cartier 99' 160,690 ... Details
  • '91 MERCEDES 560-SEL Classic ... Details
  • ’91 Mercedes 560-SEL Classi ... Details
  • 14' JON BOAT with electric s ... Details

Most Popular
  1. Former judge donates farm to benefit MSU
  2. Melissa and Paul Jones III
  3. Barbara Sue and Glenn Wilson
  1. Paul to be featured speaker at next Chamber breakfast
  2. Livingston native to retire after 23 years as Norton Healthcare CEO
  3. Three injured in collision
  1. Former judge donates farm to benefit MSU
  2. People & Business
  3. Livingston native to retire after 23 years as Norton Healthcare CEO
Discussion

Check out these recently discussed stories and voice your opinion...