Thank you for visiting paducahsun.com, the online home of The Paducah Sun.

June 2012
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

Click here to submit an event.

Court won't overturn death sentence for Woodall

Associated Press

WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court on Wednesday declined to overturn the death sentence of a man who confessed to kidnapping, raping and killing a 16-year-old girl in Kentucky.

The justices ruled 6-3 that Robert Keith Woodall was not entitled to a new sentencing hearing despite his claim that jurors received faulty instructions.

Woodall argued that the trial judge should have told the jury not to draw any negative conclusions about his refusal to take the stand at his 1998 capital sentencing hearing.

Justice Antonin Scalia said the trial judge was under no obligation to instruct the jury about drawing adverse conclusions. Scalia acknowledged that prior Supreme Court precedents have required such instructions during the guilt phase of a criminal trial and in some cases during sentencing. But he said those decisions did not "clearly establish" a broad rule for all sentencing hearings.

Woodall pleaded guilty to kidnapping Hansen on Jan. 25, 1997, from a convenience store in western Kentucky. Woodall acknowledged that he raped the girl and slit her throat twice before taking her body to Luzerne Lake and throwing it in the water. DNA evidence, fingerprints and footprints led to Woodall.

A jury imposed a death sentence, but more than a decade later, a federal court found the jury instructions were flawed and overturned that sentence. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that ruling in 2012.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Anthony Kennedy, Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas and Elena Kagan joined Scalia's opinion reversing the appeals court.

To overturn a death sentence, Scalia said, Woodall had to show the decision involved an "unreasonable application" of clearly established federal law. But that standard can be met "only if the error alleged is so obvious that there could be no fairminded disagreement about its existence," Scalia said.

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Your comment has been submitted for approval
captcha 3d1852dc4ef3435b9f994e04f2fb1f94
Top Classifieds
  • RUNNING, fixable, junk vehicles, equi ... Details
  • PILLOW TOPmattress sets NEW in plasti ... Details
  • Cash for farms & gold (270)339-8 ... Details
  • 127 Acres Lyon CountyLake Barkley- De ... Details
  • SEEING is believing! Don't buy p ... Details
  • 2010 KZ Spree 32.5 ft traveltrailer w ... Details
  • Scarlet Red Road Glide 1 owner 33K Mi ... Details
  • Ford Ranger '86 2WD, $1, 000 2 ... Details
This Week In Photos
Most Popular
  1. Sisters with local ties recognized for service
  2. A Rose for racial reconciliation
  1. Conway tours James Marine, talks jobs
  2. McCracken Indictments
  3. Local option tax will get a fresh push
  1. Doss named Scholastic All-American
  2. Sisters with local ties recognized for service

Check out these recently discussed stories and voice your opinion...